I know I was supposed to be reading Kenyon’s Dream Chaser, but there are no hard and fast rules. If there were, they’d be mine and I can break them whenever I wish.
So, what have I been reading? That would be sly if the title of this post didn’t blatantly tell you what I’ve been reading. And what do I think of Sunshine by Robin McKinley?
Hmmm, let me tell you what Neil Gaiman thinks “Pretty much perfect.” How about Jayne Ann Krentz…“Fabulous.”
These are the blurbs on the front of the book. They caught my eye. So yeah, blurbage is a great marketing tool.
Okay, so we know that some people think it’s great, some paid people even. Me? I’m not paid. Does that make my opinion more believable? Not necessarily, but it sounds good.
Now, Sunshine is not a new book by any means. It was first copyrighted in 2003. The books been around and it’s been somewhat popular on the scene. I didn’t hear about it until I saw it on the “new releases” section at Barnes and Noble. A new cover, maybe? First time in trade paperback size? (You can pay $14 for the big size or $7.99 for pocket size, new.)
Oh, you probably don’t care about all that.
Anyway, after all this time, you’d expect there to be a sequel for this book by now, but according to the writer’s blog there “probably won’t be.”
That’s kind of tragic because I really like this book and I like the characters a lot. I will agree with Krentz and say the book is fabulous. I’m not going to go so far as to say that the book is “pretty much perfect” because it isn’t.
The story moves along very well, there are a lot of twists and turns, some awesome turns of phrases and some philosophical bits that really get your synapses moving. This book, called a romance by some, is highly intelligent, has a great spin on the paranormal world, takes you to places that you never have been before. The destination is wondrous!!!
But the god-damned road is bumpy at times.
There are moments when McKinely is too indulgent in the exposition. You really get a sense that all kinds of information is being crammed into it just in case you never get to come back to the world again. After just having read that McKinley “doesn’t do re-writes” I can understand the tendency. You do need to paint the world for the reader and if you aren’t coming back to it, you’ve got to do it in limited space.
I would rather have a sequel than that though. It seems like Sunshine would be better served as a seven course meal rather than a single dinner feast after having skipped both breakfast and lunch.
Even with the every so often sense of info cram, the book is highly palatable. It’s a sweet adventure, taking the ordinary Sunshine and making her more than what she knows her self to be or capable of.
Who is Sunshine?
She’s a baker. She’s done nothing but most of her life. She has a grueling, boring life that she seems quite happy with. Her parents are divorced, she comes from a famous magic-handling family that disappeared after the War.
We come across her when she’s having a bad day, decides to forgo a weekly movie ritual with friends and family and goes to a lake, where she recalls memories of her Grandmother who taught her some basics in magic-handling.
After that, the vampires come. The story begins. It’s intense, but it’s not. It’s fast, but it’s not. The whole story is full of contradictions from the way the characters move in and out of the story to the pace of the writer’s style. Some will find this difficult to handle because we are used to the writer taking us on a ride full of anticipation that feels like it wants nothing more than to a rip a scream from your throat.
This book doesn’t.
This book would love the scream, but if all you have to give is bleating whimpers, then that’s fine, too. Here you are in charge of what you see, how you read and how fast you want to go. You might even have to re-read it to grasp the complexities of what is delivered. (Through no fault of your own, like I said, some of this shit is crammed down your cerebral throat.)
After all that what do I really want to say? Can I sum up the book in a single phrase, all blurby like?
“A fascinating, intelligent, romp that sends you spinning while you do nothing but stand still.” –Lilia DiOrfeo
© 2008